Best Fire Island Pines Vacation Rentals
-
Top location
-
Beach access
The Pines Men-Only Stay
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Fitness centre
- Saltwater pool
- Heated swimming pool
- Outdoor swimming pool
The Pines Men-Only Stay
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Fitness centre
- Saltwater pool
- Heated swimming pool
- Outdoor swimming pool
The Pines Men-Only Stay
-
Great deal
2265 Bruckner Blvd Apartments
- BBQ facilities
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Luggage storage
- Ironing facilities
2265 Bruckner Blvd Apartments
- BBQ facilities
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Luggage storage
- Ironing facilities
2265 Bruckner Blvd Apartments
Whitman Motor Lodge
- Free parking
- Air conditioning
- Heating
Whitman Motor Lodge
- Free parking
- Air conditioning
- Heating
Whitman Motor Lodge
Cheap Fire Island Pines Vacation Rentals
Fancy Studio Private Entrance
- Free parking
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Ironing facilities
- Tea and coffee facilities
- Patio
Fancy Studio Private Entrance
- Free parking
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Ironing facilities
- Tea and coffee facilities
- Patio
Fancy Studio Private Entrance
-
Guest favorite
One Dutch Hotel
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Security
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Heating
- Terrace
One Dutch Hotel
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Security
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Heating
- Terrace
One Dutch Hotel
Room In Cozy Classy Duplex
- Shared kitchen
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Sun terrace
Room In Cozy Classy Duplex
- Shared kitchen
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Sun terrace
Room In Cozy Classy Duplex
Pet Friendly Vacation Rentals Fire Island Pines
-
Popular choice
Hotel And The City, Empire State Building
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Leisure/ TV room
- Luggage storage
Hotel And The City, Empire State Building
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Leisure/ TV room
- Luggage storage
Hotel And The City, Empire State Building
Downtown New Haven, Spacious Stay By Yale - Ao Destinations
-
Car park
Charges may apply
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Tea and coffee facilities
- Heating
Downtown New Haven, Spacious Stay By Yale - Ao Destinations
-
Car park
Charges may apply
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Tea and coffee facilities
- Heating
Downtown New Haven, Spacious Stay By Yale - Ao Destinations
A Dedicated Space To Unwind
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Tea and coffee facilities
- Garden area
A Dedicated Space To Unwind
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Tea and coffee facilities
- Garden area
A Dedicated Space To Unwind
Fire Island Pines Vacation Rentals Oceanfront
Econo Lodge Hicksville - Long Island
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Tea and coffee facilities
- Heating
- Golf centre
Econo Lodge Hicksville - Long Island
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Tea and coffee facilities
- Heating
- Golf centre
Econo Lodge Hicksville - Long Island
Spacious Bedroom In A Brooklyn House Shared With Host
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Air conditioning
- Tea and coffee facilities
- Heating
- Garden area
Spacious Bedroom In A Brooklyn House Shared With Host
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Air conditioning
- Tea and coffee facilities
- Heating
- Garden area
Spacious Bedroom In A Brooklyn House Shared With Host
Brooklyn Luxury Suite
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Ironing facilities
- Jacuzzi
Brooklyn Luxury Suite
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Ironing facilities
- Jacuzzi
Brooklyn Luxury Suite
Fire Island Pines Vacation Rentals with Private Pool
Luxury Hotel-Style Room In Queens, New York
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Bar/ Lounge area
- Terrace
Luxury Hotel-Style Room In Queens, New York
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Bar/ Lounge area
- Terrace
Luxury Hotel-Style Room In Queens, New York
Cozy 2 Bedroom In A Lovely Forest Hills Neighborhood
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- 24-hour security
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Heating
Cozy 2 Bedroom In A Lovely Forest Hills Neighborhood
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- 24-hour security
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Heating
Cozy 2 Bedroom In A Lovely Forest Hills Neighborhood
Eleni'S Charming Studio
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- 24-hour security
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Tea and coffee facilities
Eleni'S Charming Studio
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- 24-hour security
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Tea and coffee facilities
Eleni'S Charming Studio
-
Best-rated
-
Private beach
The Cliffside Resort Condominiums
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Laundry
- Outdoor swimming pool
The Cliffside Resort Condominiums
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Laundry
- Outdoor swimming pool
The Cliffside Resort Condominiums
Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of Vacation Rentals in Fire Island Pines, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Price, $ | |
| The Pines Men-Only Stay |
9.8 / 10 (82 Reviews) |
From 300$ | |
| 2265 Bruckner Blvd Apartments |
9.0 / 10 (182 Reviews) |
From 86$ | |
| Whitman Motor Lodge |
8.9 / 10 (184 Reviews) |
From 99$ | |
| Fancy Studio Private Entrance |
9.3 / 10 (72 Reviews) |
From 105$ | |
| One Dutch Hotel |
8.7 / 10 (1098 Reviews) |
From 243$ |
Frequently Asked Questions
What vacation rentals in Fire Island Pines are ideal for beach lovers?
Eleni's Charming Studio and The Pines Men-Only Stay are perfect choices for beach enthusiasts. Eleni's offers easy access to the beach and a cozy atmosphere. The Pines is located right by the water with vibrant community features.
Walk to Fire Island National Seashore before 10am for the best beach spots with fewer crowds.
Which Fire Island Pines homes have stunning views?
A Dedicated Space To Unwind and The Cliffside Resort Condominiums both boast amazing views of the bay. These rentals allow you to enjoy sunset views right from your room or balcony.
Choose A Dedicated Space To Unwind for panoramic sunrises over the water every morning.
Are there family-friendly vacation rentals in Fire Island Pines?
Cozy 2 Bedroom In A Lovely Forest Hills Neighborhood is an excellent choice for families. It features two bedrooms and a living area for relaxation after a day of fun.
Create family memories by planning a beach picnic at nearby Fire Island Lighthouse; it's a scenic 20-minute walk.
Where can I find romantic vacation rentals in Fire Island Pines?
The Pines Men-Only Stay and Eleni's Charming Studio offer a romantic escape. They provide intimate settings and are close to quiet spots for sunset walks.
Book a rental near the beach to enjoy private moments watching the sunset together, especially in the evenings.
Which vacation rentals near local attractions do you recommend?
The Cliffside Resort Condominiums and A Dedicated Space To Unwind are near popular attractions, like the Fire Island Pines Art Gallery. Experience local culture through art exhibits.
Plan to visit the gallery on weekends for special exhibitions and events to enhance your stay.
What are some affordable vacation rentals in Fire Island Pines?
Econo Lodge Hicksville - Long Island and Brooklyn Luxury Suite offer budget-friendly options without sacrificing comfort. Both provide clean, cozy stays and easy access to nearby attractions.
Stay during the weekdays for lower rates; it's often cheaper than weekends for rentals like the Econo Lodge.
Which rentals in Fire Island Pines are pet-friendly?
Hotels like The Pines Men-Only Stay accommodate pets. This allows you to enjoy a vacation without leaving your pet behind.
Check with the hotel at least 48 hours in advance to confirm their pet policy and prepare accordingly.
What unique events should I not miss during my stay in Fire Island Pines?
Visit during the summer for the Annual Fire Island Pines Party, featuring live performances and a fun parade. This event engages the local community and enhances your experience.
Arrive early to grab a good spot along the parade route; it starts at 11am on the last Saturday in July.
How can I get around Fire Island Pines easily?
Biking is popular, with rentals available near the ferry docks. This method allows quick access to beaches and attractions without the hassle of parking.
Consider renting a bike for the duration of your stay to explore the coastal areas freely and at your own pace.
What are the top outdoor activities in Fire Island Pines?
Try kayaking and paddleboarding during your visit. Rentals are available at nearby beaches, making it easy to enjoy the scenic waterways.
Head to Bay Walk for a relaxing stroll along the water after your activities; it's particularly beautiful at sunset.